The truth: the reform of the voting system is not just the business of a few intellectuals, as the CAQ leader said

The Right Time: Voting System Reform Is Not Right affair of a few intellectuals, as the chief caquiste said

and Nicolas Brasseur MISE À DAY

Our Investigation Office specializes in the art of establishing the facts. Throughout the election campaign, our researchers present their findings to flush out the surprising, dubious or downright false statements of the candidates, and allow you to see more clearly.

THE STATEMENT

During the program Cinq chefs, une lection on Radio-Canada, outgoing Prime Minister François Legault spoke about a possible reform of the voting system in Quebec.

“There is no one fighting on the buses in Quebec to change the voting system. Currently, there are too many other priorities […] and so, in that sense, we decided to put that aside. We listened to the population, and that does not interest the population. Apart from a few intellectuals, Quebecers are not interested in changing the voting system,” he said on Sunday.

THE FACTS

< p>The Right Time: Voting System Reform Is Not Just About a few intellectuals as the CAQ leader said

It is wrong to claim that almost no one is in agreement with a reform of the voting system for the elections in Quebec. When questioned by journalists on Tuesday, Mr. Legault said he based his remarks on what he saw on the ground.

However, the latest data on the subject showed a marked interest from Quebecers. In 2019, a survey by the Léger firm commissioned by the New Democracy Movement (MDN) showed on the contrary that the majority of people were in agreement with a reform for a voting system proportional to votes.

Some 69 % of the 2,506 survey respondents said they wanted François Legault's government to keep its word and reform the voting system. There are also 60% of Quebecers who claimed to see a problem with the gap between the percentage of seats obtained and the percentage of the vote.

Mr. Legault said Tuesday that with the pandemic, the priorities of Quebecers have changed and that a reform no longer interests them. He gives as an example of a priority “all the work that needs to be done in the health network”.

“I know that Jean-Pierre Charbonneau, [president of MDN ], but apart from Jean-Pierre Charbonneau, who cares?” asked Mr. Legault.

The proposed voting system is one that adds proportionality to the candidates sent to the National Assembly. There would therefore be 80 constituencies with one deputy for each, in addition to 45 deputies sent according to the party's overall vote percentage. The CAQ government introduced a bill to this effect, which was finally abandoned in 2021.

-with the collaboration of Marc-André Gagnon

  • Have you spotted a false or questionable statement during the election campaign? Write to us at heurejuste@quebecormedia.com and we will check the facts.