Video of Israeli journalist in Mecca sparks controversy

A video of an Israeli journalist in Mecca creates a controversy


RYAD | An Israeli journalist has sparked controversy after the publication of a video showing him strolling through the Saudi city of Mecca, Islam's first holiest site, off-limits to non-Muslims. 

< p>The video by journalist Gil Tamary, who works for Israel's Channel 13, sparked an avalanche of backlash on social media in Saudi Arabia on Wednesday, two days after it was posted on Twitter. On Tuesday the journalist apologized for any offense he may have caused.

In his 10-minute video, the Israeli journalist is seen going to Mount Arafat, an essential and sacred stop as part of the pilgrimage to Mecca.

He himself admits that what he is doing is forbidden, pointing out that the place where he is is “a place forbidden to non -Muslims” and adding “I am the first Israeli journalist here to make a video and in Hebrew”.

Responding to protests on social media, Gil Tamary explained that his aim was “to show the importance of Mecca and the beauty of Islam”. This video “allowed many people to see for the first time a place that is so important for our Muslim brothers and sisters”, he justifies.

But his explanations did not calm anger in the media and on social networks.

A “Jew in the Holy Mosque” hashtag was created on Twitter, where one user called on the Saudi authorities to “not insult the Muslim nation […] by allowing Jews to desecrate the city of the messenger of God

Ryad never joined the Abraham Accords negotiated by Washington in 2020, which allowed Israel to normalize its relations with Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates, two Gulf countries neighboring the Saudi Arabia.

Several Israeli journalists holding foreign passports were able to travel to Saudi Arabia during and before US President Joe Biden's visit to the region last week.

The Gil Tamary's video has also been denounced as a “disgrace” by Twitter accounts encouraging diplomatic normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia, as have some of his fellow Israelis.

“There are things that need to be said: what Gil Tamary did is a disgrace to journalism me,” wrote on Twitter Yoav Limor, another Israeli journalist who recently visited the kingdom.

Questioned by AFP, the Saudi authorities did not respond.